HIGH SPEED IMPACT vs. DITCHING.
GROK: The debris evidence, particularly the right flaperon, does not support a single clean binary. Forensic configuration analysis and satellite kinematics favor a high-energy water impact with surfaces in the cruise position; fluid–structure modeling of the flaperon itself favors that the surface was still attached when it met the water, rather than having separated in flight and free-fallen. ### Flaperon damage pattern The flaperon recovered on RĂ©union (confirmed as 9M-MRO) has fractured hinge fittings, localized leading-edge dents and cracks, and—most distinctively—loss of the trailing edge aft of the rear spar. French DGA examinations (judicial technical assistance) and subsequent independent work concluded that this trailing-edge failure is the expected result of hydrodynamic loading while the flaperon was still mounted, not of an in-flight separation followed by free fall. The independent analyses (CAPTIO / Kamoulakos, published in 3AF and AIAA Aviation forum papers) adapt...