THE TRUTH ABOUT WSPR AND THE TERMINATED O.I. SEARCH.

 







https://whereismh370today.blogspot.com/2026/05/hydroacoustic-signals-and-wspr.html



I have been swept up in the WSPR 'has to be the spot' hype on Daily Airline News podcasts - episode after episode.

I even got A.I. to 'look' favourably upon the WSPR zone in a blatant exercise of confirmation bias (as per link above).

This incidentally illustrates that A.I. can be subject to bias and has a way to go in terms of development.

The passing of Geoffrey Thomas has been deeply saddening and I respect his legacy -but finding MH370 in the broader WSPR zone is futile and of no meaningful service to the MH370 families desperately seeking closure - otherwise it WOULD have been searched.

MH370, like TSS Waratah, disappeared without trace and as bitter a pill as that is to swallow, it is in the case of MH370 after 12 years REALITY does need to sink in.

I have now challenged GROK A.I. to put the record straight in the following more truth-seeking analaysis of the MH370 status quo, but many of the answers remain illusive to this day.

But kudos to Ocean Infinity for searching in good faith !!!!


GROK:


This extract is a masterclass in MH370-enthusiast hedging, selective emphasis, and post-hoc pattern-seeking dressed up as sober analysis.
It starts with reasonable caveats, then slowly builds a narrative that two inconclusive, contested datasets (one peer-reviewed but criticized hydroacoustic paper, one fringe radio-propagation claim) show "loose but intriguing" alignment.
They don't.
The piece repeatedly softens hard failures into "plausible" or "worth noting," while ignoring why Ocean Infinity (and the ATSB before them) treated this stuff as background noise rather than a search priority.Ocean Infinity Did Not Stop "Prematurely"
Ocean Infinity's 2018 search (and their later 2025–2026 effort) targeted the highest-probability zones derived from Inmarsat satellite data, fuel exhaustion modeling, and debris drift analysis. They mapped large areas with autonomous underwater vehicles, found nothing, and stopped when the contract/priority areas were exhausted. Their public statements were clear: they have high confidence the wreckage is not where they looked.
Calling this "premature" is pure cope from people whose preferred locations (often WSPR-derived or "further north/south" variants) sit outside those zones.
No credible, multi-validated hydroacoustic detection existed to redirect them.
If there had been a smoking-gun signal with multi-station confirmation and official backing, it would have been factored in.
There wasn't.
Ocean Infinity followed the data they had; they didn't ignore "plausible" alternatives that failed basic scrutiny.Hydroacoustics: Theoretically Interesting, Practically Inconclusive and Contested
Sound propagation in the SOFAR channel is real. Historical aircraft crashes have produced detectable hydroacoustic signals at long range in some cases. The energy calculations in the extract (high-speed impact ~4 GJ equivalent) are rough order-of-magnitude ballparks and not wildly wrong.
But the leap to "reasonable chance Cape Leeuwin picked up MH370" collapses under scrutiny:
  • Kadri et al. (2024) is the centerpiece. It is peer-reviewed in Scientific Reports. It analyzed historical crashes and looked in the narrow official post-7th-arc window. It found one weak single-station candidate at HA01 (Cape Leeuwin/H01W) around 00:52 UTC on a bearing of ~306°. No corresponding signal at Diego Garcia (H08). The paper itself stresses this does not definitively locate MH370, notes the single-station limitation, and recommends controlled calibration explosions along the 7th arc to test propagation.
  • Real hydroacoustic experts have pushed back hard. Criticisms include questionable azimuth/bearing calculations (possible systematic errors compared to earlier Curtin University work), and the very real possibility that the candidate is an Antarctic ice event (HA01 routinely picks these up from the south). One detailed critique called for retraction over azimuth issues.
  • No CTBTO endorsement. No multi-station triangulation. No wreckage correlation. Earlier Curtin-era signals (~01:34 UTC, ~301°) were also investigated and left inconclusive. The extract acknowledges some of this but still frames the work as "scientifically meaningful" and "viable tool" that "narrows possibilities." It narrows them only in the sense that one ambiguous blip exists in a noisy dataset.
The extract's probability assessment ("plausible that Cape Leeuwin recorded a weak/ambiguous signal... probability of some acoustic signature existing... higher") is the classic motte-and-bailey.
Yes, something might be in the data.
No, it has not been shown to be MH370, and experts dispute whether the candidate even points where claimed.WSPR: Fringe Claim, Not Science
The extract correctly notes at one point that there is "no established or documented direct correlation" between the hydroacoustic candidate(s) and WSPR-derived locations.
Then it spends thousands of words arguing there is "loose but non-trivial directional, distance, and timing compatibility."
This is where it roasts itself.

Richard Godfrey's WSPR analysis for MH370 is not accepted by the scientific community. The inventor of WSPR himself (Nobel laureate Joe Taylor) called the idea of using historical WSPR data to track MH370 "crazy."
Independent technical reviews (e.g., by Victor Iannello) found the claimed anomalies do not hold up under scrutiny — signal strengths are too weak, the method isn't designed for this, and there's heavy risk of cherry-picking or confirmation bias.
The ATSB has been politely non-committal but noted that Godfrey's proposed zones overlap areas already searched without result.
The "Loose Compatibility" Is Mostly Illusion
The extract's own numbers expose the weakness:
  • Distance from HA01 to the main WSPR point (~29.13°S, 99.93°E): ~1,483 km. Kadri's reference distance to the 7th arc in that sector: ~1,586 km. Close enough.
  • Timing: Loose. Requires ~15–16 minutes of post-ping flight/glide at plausible speeds. Possible under some assumptions, not diagnostic.
  • Bearing: This is the killer. The Kadri candidate is at 306°. The great-circle bearing from HA01 (~34.89°S, 114.14°E) to the claimed WSPR crash point is ~291.6°.
That's a ~14.4° difference.
The paper claims bearing precision of ±0.4°. A 14° offset is not "good match" or "strikingly close." It is a significant directional mismatch.
The 306° ray at relevant range puts a hypothetical source noticeably north of the WSPR coordinates. The extract even calculates what a ~292° signal would imply (almost exactly on the WSPR point) — which only highlights that the actual candidate isn't on that ray.
Calling this "good on direction," "intriguing geometric fit," or "stronger than random chance" requires heroic levels of generosity. It's the same rhetorical move as saying "the compass pointed roughly northwest, and the destination is also in the western hemisphere — compatible!"
Other hydroacoustic candidates fare even worse against the specific WSPR point. Northern/Java candidates are in entirely different ocean basins. Curtin-era signals have their own issues.
No published source performs a rigorous joint back-projection because there's nothing rigorous to joint-analyze. The "compatibility" is an after-the-fact observational note by the extract's author, not evidence.
Bottom Line:
This extract is what happens when you start with two weak, single-station/poorly-validated signals in a noisy environment, assume the official 7th-arc narrative (or slight variants), and then massage numbers until you can say "hey, these point kinda-sorta in the same general sector if you squint and allow for uncertainties we just spent paragraphs downplaying."
Hydroacoustics is a legitimate field. Kadri's work on historical crashes is useful for future incidents and correctly calls for calibration shots.
It has not provided a breakthrough for MH370.
The candidate signal remains unconfirmed, contested on technical grounds, and insufficient to move the search needle.
WSPR tracking of MH370 is even weaker — rejected by its own creator and multiple technical reviewers.
Ocean Infinity didn't stop prematurely; they searched where the best-validated data said to search.
The fact that no wreckage was found there is a problem for all theories that put the plane in or near those zones (including the official one and the WSPR-adjacent ones the extract tries to rehabilitate).
Continuing to treat ambiguous hydro blips and unvalidated radio anomalies as meaningful "compatibility" is why this case attracts endless speculation instead of closure.

The mystery persists because the physical evidence (debris drift, satellite data, exhaustive seabed mapping) and the alternative signals refuse to line up cleanly.
This extract doesn't resolve that tension — it papers over it with "loose but intriguing." That's not critical analysis.

That's wishful thinking with extra steps.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

GROK'S SEARCH BLOCK AND MAG SWARM.

THE TRUTH, NOT CONSPIRACY THEORIES - THE FLYDUBAI INCIDENT.

HYDROACOUSTIC SIGNALS AND WSPR.